It was good, and the plot was very, very interesting and quite well written. We had a few hesitations addressed and Amish community was written an interesting and respectful way. Only problem: my main problem from Book 1, Temptation, was not addressed. I still don't feel like Noah and Rose are really truly in love. It feels very superficial and young and melodramatic without anything genuine. This is quite sad because even though the whole idea is great and the writing is lovely, I'm not convinced.